Skip to content
Talent Acquisition & Recruitment

Skills Over CVs: The Hiring Shift Hospitality Refuses to Make

The hospitality industry has a hiring problem it cannot solve. And it may be looking in the wrong places for answers. Recruitment and retention remain practical challenges for hospitality employers.…

Sarah Shaw 3 min read Talent Acquisition & Recruitment
Watercolour of a hotel candidate handing a plain key-card wallet to a guest while a manager observes a practical guest-service assessment.
Illustration: WINC Wire

The hospitality industry has a hiring problem it cannot solve. And it may be looking in the wrong places for answers.

Recruitment and retention remain practical challenges for hospitality employers. Pay, working conditions and the way candidates are assessed all deserve attention.

Meanwhile, a quiet revolution has transformed hiring elsewhere. It is called skills-based hiring. Hospitality showed lower adoption than other industries in TestGorilla’s 2024 survey.

What works everywhere else

TestGorilla’s State of Skills-Based Hiring 2025 report reported that 85 per cent of surveyed employers used skills-based methods. The 2025 research surveyed employers and job seekers in the US and UK. Separately, its 2024 report found that 90 per cent of employers using skills-based hiring reported fewer mis-hires, and 94 per cent considered it more predictive of on-the-job success than CVs. These are survey responses, not guaranteed outcomes.

The logic is simple. Rather than screening for degrees and years of experience, employers assess what candidates can actually do. Problem-solving. Communication. Adaptability.

For hospitality, where soft skills define service quality, this should be obvious.

The uncomfortable truth

In TestGorilla’s 2024 survey, hotel and food services had the lowest skills-based hiring adoption among the industries surveyed, at 54 per cent.

In that same 2024 sample, marketing stood at 95 per cent and construction at 89 per cent. The comparison describes the surveyed employers rather than every employer in those industries.

The irony is painful. Hotels complain about candidates who look good on paper but cannot connect with guests. They watch new hires leave within months. And yet the industry keeps screening CVs for years of similar experience – the very approach that perpetuates these problems.

What it actually means

Skills-based hiring is not about lowering standards. It is about measuring what matters.

A restaurant implementing self-service kiosks may value employees who learn technology quickly over those with five years of food service experience. A hotel benefits more from candidates who demonstrate empathy and composure under pressure than those with hospitality diplomas.

When evaluating hiring software, check the assessment and applicant-tracking features included in the specific plan. Pricing and capabilities vary, and a scheduling platform should not be assumed to include a full recruitment workflow.

The choice ahead

The survey suggests room for wider adoption in hospitality, alongside attention to pay and working conditions.

Skills-based hiring will not fix wages or scheduling pressures. But it addresses something fundamental: finding people who can do the job, regardless of how their CV reads.

The practical question is which job-relevant skills an employer can assess consistently before making an offer.

About the author

Sarah Shaw

Sarah Shaw is a content writer that doesn't make you want to fake a meeting. She's curious about the mechanics of how things actually work, spots the slip between intention and reality, and writes for people who need to know "what's in it for me?" Her storytelling turns corporate speak into conversations. Witty when it counts, invested in her readers, and genuinely playful about the serious stuff. Grab a seat, she's all ears.

More Post

Join 1,200+ HR & Hospitality Leaders

Your Weekly Dose of HR Wisdom, Trends & Actionable Insights

Every Thursday morning — curated intelligence on talent, leadership, technology and culture. Read by professionals at Hilton, IHG, Marriott, Accor and leading independents worldwide.

No spam, ever. Unsubscribe any time.